layos85 & Lord Marter Secret Diplomacy [cleared] BG

[mickes]

Accused:

layos85
Lord Marter



The accused are suspected of:

Conducting Secret Diplomacy

Game number(s):

Game 12254029
Game 11779630
Game 11807451
Game 11816547
Game 11842213
Game 11844045
Game 11884264
Game 11884802
Game 12076721

Comments:Lord Marter only attacking me and let lagos85 grov bigger so both attack me. Checking lagos85 game history and found out that 8 of 12 victorys in standard game Lord Marter have been involved, to take up winners stat to 50% for lagos85.

[BGtheBrain]

Game 12254029 - Still foggy
Game 11779630 - no - 2 player game
Game 11807451 - no
Game 11816547 - no
Game 11842213 - no
Game 11844045 - no - 2 player game
Game 11884264 - no
Game 11884802 - no
Game 12076721 - no

I think people are confused about secret diplomacy isn't. Secret diplomacy isn't when an opponent makes an attack that you think he shouldn't have made or doesn't make an attack that you think he should have. When someone makes a retaliatory attack many times someone else will get an advantage from that attack, that doesn't make it secret diplomacy.

I couldn't find anything in the log that would convince me of secret diplomacy. Your evidence is more what you think he should have done and that isn't enough to convince me of SD.

layos85 has been cleared of secret diplomacy
Lord Marter has been cleared of secret diplomacy