Change name back to Foundry Discussion?

[sailorseal]

???

[RjBeals]

i sort of agree. Then new title is kind of dumb.

[TaCktiX]

The new title is very dumb and almost seems like a joke forum even more so than the Tower of Babble. Foundry Discussion was appropriate, and until some other forum exists that makes that name confusing, it should stay that way.

[sailorseal]

Exactly

[pepperonibread]

I'm with yall. We're all bweesness down here in the foundry.

[yeti_c]

I'm with yall. We're all bweesness down here in the foundry.

Shudddup and finish the Germany map!!!!

viewtopic.php?f=10&t=47140

C.

[el-presidente]

Foundry Discussion was a much better name.

[cairnswk]

i sort of agree. Then new title is kind of dumb.

i concur

[bryguy]

i sort of agree. Then new title is kind of dumb.

i concur

I also concur

I'm with yall. We're all bweesness down here in the foundry.

Shudddup and finish the Germany map!!!!

viewtopic.php?f=10&t=47140

C.

As yeti has so kindly put it, shudddup and finish the Germany map

[pepperonibread]

i sort of agree. Then new title is kind of dumb.

i concur

I also concur

I'm with yall. We're all bweesness down here in the foundry.

Shudddup and finish the Germany map!!!!

viewtopic.php?f=10&t=47140

C.

As yeti has so kindly put it, shudddup and finish the Germany map

Fine... when we get back our foundry discussion.

[AndyDufresne]

I'd rather this work the other way around maybe. Finish Germany and we'll get Foundry Discussion back....


--Andy

[oaktown]

The idea behind the name change was that we want it to be more than discussion - we want this to be a place to host competitions, post mapmaker call-outs, celebrate the newsletter, share tips & tricks, etc. Basically this subforum is for everything that is Not Maps.

I'm not wedded to the name, but I do think something more light and friendly was needed. I think we're open to other suggestions.

???

That's not a suggestion.

[LED ZEPPELINER]

The idea behind the name change was that we want it to be more than discussion - we want this to be a place to host competitions, post mapmaker call-outs, celebrate the newsletter, share tips & tricks, etc. Basically this subforum is for everything that is Not Maps.

I'm not wedded to the name, but I do think something more light and friendly was needed. I think we're open to other suggestions.

???

That's not a suggestion.

how about just take out the (mostly) becuase in the how to use this subforum, it says that the foundry discussion is a place for not maps, sort of

[MrBenn]

The (mostly) was added to the name, as we plan to use this subforum to run future mapmaking competitions, so occasionally there will be maps in here

[BrendanGillis]

What's wrong with "General Discussion" ?

[blakebowling]

What's wrong with "General Discussion" ?

We already have one of those

[samuelc812]

Why not "Foundry Discussion (Mostly)" ? or "Mostly Foundry Discussion" ?

[Kaplowitz]

Being that the main forum is called "Map Foundry" maybe we could stick with that sort of theme by calling this "Map Guild" or something...a place where you learn the trade?

[the.killing.44]

Being that the main forum is called "Map Foundry" maybe we could stick with that sort of theme by calling this "Map Guild" or something...a place where you learn the trade?

But besides the very good threads stickied, it's not. The announcements in the Main are the real spots, and other than that just practicing.

I like sam's suggestions.

.44

[wcaclimbing]

I vote for returning it to be "Foundry Discussion".

[sailorseal]

What's wrong with "General Discussion" ?

Why not foundry discussion and map competitions?

[the.killing.44]

What's wrong with "General Discussion" ?

Why not foundry discussion and map competitions?

Way too long, I vote "Foundry Discussion" or "Foundry Discussion (Mostly)"

.44

[Premier2k]

Being that the main forum is called "Map Foundry" maybe we could stick with that sort of theme by calling this "Map Guild" or something...a place where you learn the trade?

I second that! Maybe "Cartographers Guild"

Premier2k

[oaktown]

Maybe "Cartographers Guild"

taken.

A little change is good every now and then, people. I would support a name change that kept the Foundry metaphor alive. The Break Room? Smoking Area?

[bryguy]

Being that the main forum is called "Map Foundry" maybe we could stick with that sort of theme by calling this "Map Guild" or something...a place where you learn the trade?

I second that! Maybe "Cartographers Guild"

Premier2k

lol good idea, but kinda taken already by the Cartographers Guild: http://www.cartographersguild.com/

so far I think the best suggestion has been Foundry Discussion (mostly)