You dont need a small map to get out of the ideas sub-forum. But your map does need to meet the size guidelines. Something qwert has been told several times, but refuses to do.

I dont think the river name is really needed. You didnt have them on the eastern front map.
To me, it also looks more like Coire than Loire.

The dots were WAY better.
If the lines were in the original map that was put up for vote, I would have voted for a different map.

I voted no, but only because Im not a fan of the map. I understand the sensitivity of the subject but as cairnswk said,
i don't just create maps to allow punters to fight over territories. I also create these maps to bring awareness of some the horrors of what war brings
If people want to bring ...

The river is south of Porto, not north.

Im wondering if there is something more appropriate instead of Porto for that territory? Maybe nicas or _sioux_ could help with that?
I completely understand why you dont want to start the map again, but I think you should try to get the map as accurate as ...

nicas wrote:Estermoz it's in fact Estremoz.

Also, Covilha.. on the large the a looks a bit messy. It also looks more like Covllha.

opiton A doesnt have france in it.

The mountains between Lyon and Ligurian Army dont quite go to the border at the top. It might just be the white glow making it look that way, but it looks like there is a small gap.

Nothing was ever decided upon, and last I read, something else was going to be tried.

The current army shadows are kind of pointless. I'd either ditch them or go for something a bit more substantial.

They were being worked on back a few pages. Since then, nothing has been done. The shadows were brought up... that hasnt been resolved yet. Why hassle for quenching? Hassle for the ...

those mountains are alot better. they at least look like mountains.
The beach however isnt great. Not sandy enough.

As far as I know, the army shadows havent been fixed/decided on. Something that was mentioned weeks ago now.

I have a problem with the beaches. They look too yellow. Beaches arent fluro yellow like yours are. Yours kind of look radioactive.

I also agree that the mountains need work. They dont blend with the rest of your map. The colour of your map is a pale greeny-brown. The colour of your mountains need ...

DiM, can you explain to me how working on a bigger map than is allowed is good?
What is the point of putting army shadows on a map if you are just going to have to reduce your map and potentially re-work territories?

making rules on the spot is not your job.
I never said it was my job, and it ...

I think size should be considered before any map leaves the ideas sub-forum. There are VERY clear guidelines on size but people ignore them. If their map wont be moved until it fits with the guidelines, it might stop people ignoring those guidelines.

DiM, the size of maps is something you ignore on ...

the colours and style you have are too much like the san francisco map for me at the moment.

ah k. good luck with your maps then.

I think that a lot of people are not participating as much due to school starting, moving to universities, summer ending, vacations, etc. But yes, I do notice the decline in activity. I too will be leaving in about 2-3 weeks .

Im curious, if you are leaving soon why are you trying to make a map ...

misterman10 wrote:I think that a lot of people are not participating as much due to school starting, moving to universities, summer ending, vacations, etc. But yes, I do notice the decline in activity. I too will be leaving in about 2-3 weeks.

Im curious, if you are leaving soon why are you trying to make a map?

the most recent image is at the bottom of page 31.

Qwert has explained why he wants to keep the current background, he has also made it lighter as a compromise. I think the background discussion should be left alone now.

I agree that the barriers & tunnels look better now.

Im wondering if it would look better if you slightly rotatated the barriers between Mount Suribachi and 5th MD. At the moment, to me it looks more like a railway or something.

Also, the colours in the legend dont seem to match the colours on the ...

In your eastern from map, you have the 3 star territories. Are you doing the same thing in this map? will there be 3 stars?

Yes they are,but first people must look terittory colours and when majority agree with colours,then i can go to next step.

If you are having the 3 stars, you are better ...

As concern of Extrabonuses,vell first i have some opinion that Bonuses is high(3 army for 3 terittory) and if game start with only 2 player somebody will get bonuses right in begining.Also to many player say that bonuses for russian is high and in these way i balanced that nobody can been in ...

In your eastern from map, you have the 3 star territories. Are you doing the same thing in this map? will there be 3 stars?

I dont remember neutral 6's being discussed either. It is something that should have been brought up and may even need to be revised.